Although MSBs are owned by the people who hold deposits there, these people are neither stockholders nor members. They have no say in how the bank operates or uses its money. They simply earn interest on their accounts in the form of dividends.
Acronym: MSBAlternate name: mutual institution; savings bank
MSBs aren’t as popular as they once were, but 449 of them still exist today, according to data from the FDIC. The five largest mutual savings banks by asset size include:
How a Mutual Savings Bank Works
Today, mutual savings banks operate as full-service institutions, offering all the same services you’d find at a regular bank or credit union. Take Liberty Bank, for example. It’s the largest mutual savings bank in Connecticut, with 62 local branches and more than $7 billion in assets under management. It offers almost every type of banking product, including personal and business accounts, digital banking, mortgages, loans, insurance, and even investment services. But MSBs didn’t always look like this.
How Mutual Savings Banks Got Their Start
The first mutual savings bank was created in Philadelphia in 1816 as a way to give working-class families a safe place to store their money and earn interest. This was pretty revolutionary at the time, considering most banks shut out low-wage workers in favor of working with retail and commercial businesses instead. Initially, MSBs only offered federal and state government bonds. But within a few years, their services grew to include industrial bonds, blue-chip stocks, mortgage loans, and other collateralized lendings. By the end of World War II, mortgage loans were the biggest moneymaker for MSBs, making up 75% of the industry’s assets. MSBs began to pop up everywhere in the U.S. between 1820 and 1910, as the total number of institutions skyrocketed from 10 to 637. But this heyday came to an end in the 1970s and ‘80s as rising interest rates, increased competition, and legal regulations led to the entire MSB industry operating at a $3.3 billion loss by the early 1980s. Today, the most successful mutual savings banks are those that operate under mutual holding companies.
Pros and Cons of a Mutual Savings Bank
Pros Explained
Depositor-owned: While traditional banks have their shareholders’ best interests at heart, MSBs are there to serve you, the customer. As such, they have more of an incentive to keep you happy and satisfied. Friendly customer service: Similar to credit unions, MSBs are known for having friendly customer service representatives who take the time to build lasting relationships with you. FDIC-insured deposits: Similar to traditional banks, MSB deposits are FDIC-insured up to the legal limit, so you can have peace of mind knowing you’d get your money back if the bank went under. Community-focused: MSBs focus on serving their local communities, whether it’s by building relationships with depositors, offering competitive interest rates, or giving back to the community.
Cons Explained
Not controlled by members: Being part “owner” of an MSB sounds great, but you have no say in how the company is operated or what it does with its assets. No large, national presence: A small, localized presence means it may be harder to access your money when traveling abroad or out of state. You may also have smaller customer service windows than you would with a nationwide bank that operates 24/7.Many are going public to raise money: Many MSBs are converting from mutual forms to stock forms to raise money, expand operations, and compete with larger banks. Although you get first dibs on stock purchases as an “owner” of the company, over time, the qualities that make MSBs attractive may start to diminish as they begin to look like every other bank.Behind the times in terms of technology: MSBs are often smaller institutions that have to merge with larger institutions to compete with the IT infrastructure and sleek user interfaces offered by big-name banks like Chase and Citibank.
Mutual Savings Bank vs. Credit Union
On the surface, MSBs and credit unions look the same: They’re owned by depositors instead of shareholders, they serve the community, and they’re known for having attractive interest rates and good customer service. This chart highlights their differences: The primary difference is in how they’re operated: MSBs are depositor-owned, while commercial banks are shareholder-owned. For example, out of the five largest MSBs in the U.S. Liberty Bank is the only one not categorized as a mutual holding company. In other words, it’s the only one that’s truly still depositor-owned.
