When a company manufactures or sells a product, it may choose to price it a bit higher because it’s for women. In most cases, the difference between these products and comparable products for men is very minor. It may simply be the color or package design. The pink tax makes it more expensive for women to buy what they need to live their everyday lives. For example, according to investment bank JPMorgan Chase, by many estimates, the pink tax costs women an average of $1,300 per year.
Examples of the Pink Tax
For example, at the drugstore, you may notice that some razors may be pink in color and have a woman on the package, yet they are essentially the same as those that are blue with a man on the package. This marketing tactic is to entice certain people to buy certain products over others. And in that, the ones that are marketed toward women tend to cost more. Products that could be used by any gender, but may cost more when marketed toward women, include:
SoapLotionShampooDeodorantLaxativesClothesToysTravel toiletries
The pink tax dates back to at least the 1990s when a report from California’s Assembly Office of Research found that 64% of stores in several major cities charged more to wash and dry-clean a woman’s blouse than a man’s button-up shirt. The subject gained national attention and has since spurred various attempts at instituting regulation to remove the pink tax. In a 2015 study by the New York City Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA), researchers surveyed 35 product categories that may upcharge women. Across the sample, DCA found that women’s products cost more 42% of the time, while men’s products cost more 18% of the time.
Is the Pink Tax Legal?
The pink tax is technically legal in most states. New York state is the only state that placed a ban on the pink tax. In April 2020, former Gov. Andrew Cuomo signed a proposal to ban the pink tax, and it went into effect on Sept. 30, 2020. The measure requires certain service providers to provide price lists for standard services and notifies them that gender-based price discrimination is prohibited under state law. If businesses violate the law, they are subject to civil penalties. While the pink tax is still legal and exists in some states, the Pink Tax Repeal Act is an attempt to ban it. Introduced in April 2019 as H.R. 2048 by Rep. Jackie Speier and again in June 2021, the Pink Tax Repeal Act would make it illegal for companies to charge higher prices based on gender for products and services. Since the Pink Tax Repeal Act does have supporters, and New York has put an end to the pink tax, there is a chance the pink tax will eventually become illegal in every state.
Common Items With a Pink Tax
The pink tax can be applied to various products and services, with beauty- and health-related products or services being the most common. In March 2022, The Balance analyzed products to see how much more they may cost because of a pink tax. According to the analysis, products cost 13% more when they were marketed toward women because of the pink tax. The Balance looked at the prices for the following products:
Razor cartridgesDeodorantsShaving creamsRazorsHair-care productsBody washesLotions
Razor cartridges marketed toward women cost more than the other products, at nearly 25% more than those marketed toward men, according to The Balance’s analysis. Lotion was the most equally priced item. The pink tax can also be seen in products and services marketed toward girls, not just adult women. According to the New York City DCA report, on average, children’s clothing marketed toward females costs an average of 4% more than male children’s clothing, and toys and accessories cost an average of 7% more.
Pink Tax vs. Tampon Tax
Several states apply sales tax to menstrual items, which are deemed necessary for women. The sales tax amount varies from state to state and is based on the tax code in each individual state.
